Criticism Theory

All the Difference in the World: Postcoloniality and the by Natalie Melas

By Natalie Melas

This booklet is ready tradition and comparability. beginning with the background of the self-discipline of comparative literature and its forgotten relation to the positivist comparative approach, it inquires into the assumption of comparability in a postcolonial global. comparability used to be Eurocentric by means of exclusion whilst it utilized simply to ecu literature, and Eurocentric via discrimination while it tailored evolutionary types to put ecu literature on the vanguard of human improvement. This publication argues that inclusiveness isn't a adequate reaction to postcolonial and multiculturalist demanding situations since it leaves the foundation of equivalence unquestioned. the purpose isn't really just to deliver extra items lower than comparability, yet quite to check the method of comparability. The e-book bargains a brand new method of the either/or of relativism and universalism, during which comparability is both very unlikely or assimilatory, through focusing in its place on a variety of different types of “incommensurability”—comparisons during which there's a flooring for comparability yet no foundation for equivalence. every one bankruptcy develops a selected kind of such cultural comparability from readings of vital novelists (Joseph Conrad, Simone Schwartz-Bart), poets (Aimé Césaire, Derek Walcott), and theorists (Edouard Glissant, Jean-Luc Nancy).

Show description

Read Online or Download All the Difference in the World: Postcoloniality and the Ends of Comparison PDF

Best criticism & theory books

ABC of Influence: Ezra Pound and the Remaking of American Poetic Tradition

During this first full-length research of Pound's impact on American poetry after global struggle II, seashore argues that Pound's experimental mode created a new culture of poetic writing in the United States. usually ignored by way of educational critics and excluded from the "canon" of yankee poetic writing, Charles Olson, Robert Duncan, and later participants of this experimental culture have maintained the feel of an American avant garde in accordance with Pound's modernist experiments of the 1910s and Twenties.

Introduction to Literary Hermeneutics

Peter Szondi is greatly considered as being one of the so much amazing postwar literary critics. this primary English version of 1 of his so much lucid and fascinating sequence of lectures, translated by way of Martha Woodmansee and with a foreword through Joel Weinsheimer, opens up his paintings in hermeneutics to English-speaking readers.

Henry James and the ’Woman Business’

This can be a old critique of Henry James in terms of nineteenth-century feminism and women's fiction. Habegger has dropped at gentle wide new documentation on James's tangled connections with what used to be inspiration and written approximately ladies in his time. The emphasis is both on his lifestyles and on his fictions.

W. S. Merwin (Bloom's Major Poets)

Deals a biographical profile of the poet and gives analyses and demanding perspectives of his paintings, together with The inebriated within the Furnace, For the Anniversary of My demise, and The River of Bees. .

Additional resources for All the Difference in the World: Postcoloniality and the Ends of Comparison

Sample text

This impulse to overcome his passions was first awakened in Harry as a result of his feelings of guilt over shooting Carroll may be read as symbolically encoding the Peggy Sheridan episode. Ormond’s unrestrained male aggressiveness leads to his literal wounding of Carroll upon their first meeting. Ormond leaves a party at Ulick’s estate under the influence of alcohol in order to search for Ulick’s son Marcus, whose mother worries that he is in danger from the Irish peasantry: 32 Dora is in a sense Edgeworth’s version of the wild Irish girl.

22 Irishness and Womanhood in Nineteenth-Century British Writing have commented on Edgeworth’s influence on Scott since. Connections between Owenson and Scott, on the other hand, have rarely been made. ”20 Still another point of contact between Waverley and The Wild Irish Girl are the ways in which both novels make use of the Henriad. The significance of Owenson’s invocation of Shakespeare’s second history tetralogy is great not only for its probable, though unacknowledged, influence on Scott (as well as writers such as Edgeworth and Trollope).

Her elevated intellect and spirit are repeatedly asserted to be what seduces him. At the same time the novel recognizes that the resulting new equality for women will be unsettling, but nevertheless may still be embraced by people with traditional attitudes. ”30 Glorvina, unlike many traditional “heroines,” is not merely passed as a possession from one male to the next. She clearly shares power in the rule of her people, first with her father, and upon her marriage with Horatio. The social and cultural implications of this formulation seem worthy of more recognition than Owenson enjoys from modern critics.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.16 of 5 – based on 38 votes